Skip to main content

Cinders by Michelle Davidson Argyle

I just finished reading Michelle Davidson Argyle's highly anticipated novella, Cinders, which is now available in ebook and paper formats. Nice work, Michelle!

This was an interesting continuance of the well-known Cinderella tale. Its dark tone and bittersweetness resonate with old versions of the Cinderella story and its sometimes horrific variants. But this is not such a "grim" story; it has just enough grit and heartache to serve as a satisfying counterpoint to the sweet, cute versions of Cinderella popularized in contemporary children's films and books.

Argyle's prose is lovely but clean and smooth. She gives just enough detail in a short format to create a rich backdrop containing many elements of the familiar and the unexpected, of fantasy and realism.

The plot hinges upon Cinderella's love choices, but it is more of a literary story than a romance. Argyle's Cinderella is neither a strong, brave heroine nor a saccharine Mary Sue. She is a very real, conflicted woman with her own desires, struggles, and uncertainties. On the surface, her journey seems motivated by finding her one true love, but it becomes more apparent that her search is a larger one, for purpose and her place in the world.

One of my favorite things about this story is how complex and psychologically real the characters feel, contrasted with their fantastic, magical setting. Some readers have been surprised by Argyle's characterization of Cinderella, feeling that she is not likeable enough. Certainly she is not the girl portrayed by Disney. But as someone who loves both ancient and modern stories, I found her imperfect nature to be both realistic and true to many narrative traditions.

Argyle's take on the Cinderella story is a fresh and new one, but it contains echoes of the ancient. Her Cinderella character reminds me of female folk heroines from Eastern European and Native American traditions, among others. Unlike most of the flat leading ladies in the writings of the Brothers Grimm, Argyle's Cinderella is not uniformly humble and meek. She is adventurous, curious, passionate, and sometimes weary, confused, or fearful. Like the figure Kochinnenako, Yellow Woman of the American Southwest, Argyle's Cinderella is both familiar and unusual. Like Yellow Woman, she chooses to break the rules, and her choice transforms her entire world with the power to bring salvation, destruction, or a mixture of both.

Cinders is a fast-paced, exciting read with depth and tension. It was a delight to read. And I hear that Michelle Davidson Argyle has ideas for a couple more fairy tale novellas in the works! Watch for more fantastic, well crafted treats by this imaginative debut author.


  1. I absolutely LOVE what you have to say about Cinderella echoing the ancient. That just gave me goosebumps. Thank you for this fantastic review!!!

  2. I agree with your review. You echoed many of my thoughts of the story... Very well put.

  3. I really, really need to get my (virtual) hands on that novella!!!


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ich Liebe Rammstein: Till

UPDATE: After purging his sillies on the side project LINDEMANN and participating in another Rammstein documentary video, Till has begun work on a seventh Rammstein album, estimated to be released in 2017. 

October 2017 is the release date of a NatGeo photo book of Till's travels in the Yukon with Joey Kelly: Mein Gehasster Freund Yukon

Yukon Ho!

For fresh squeezed gossip juice, here's a bad (as in so good) romance. Till Lindemann
Till Lindemann is the only living human who could kick Chuck Norris's ass, but he doesn't, because they go on emo hunting trips together. The source of this fact, Urban Dictionary, also provides the following essential details: "Till Lindemann is the anthropomorphic personification of pure masculinity who invented the often-lethal dance move: The Till Hammer..." "He challenges the definition of masculine..." "Every German fertility clinic features a cardboard cutout of Till Lindemann choking a shark with one hand, whils…

Ich Liebe Rammstein: Richard

Richard Z. Kruspe
Richard Zven Kruspe is Rammstein's founding father, lead guitarist, and natural frontman. He's gregarious, well-spoken in both German and English, a professional showman, and an enthusiastic promoter for the band. In German, his name is pronounced "REE-kard," and in Germanglish, "Reeshard," or "Reesh" for short. Richard is sexy, and he knows it. To many Rammstein fans, he is the cuuuuuuute one. His Facebook page would have you believe it.

Legend has it that Richard has a lovechild with lead singer Till Lindeman. The myth is based in complicated facts and figures, including one unconventional love triangle. Circa 1990, Richard and Till were in a band together (along with future Rammstein rhythm guitarist Paul Landers) with the cheeky name First Arsch. Till, the drummer, was a single father of a little girl at the time, the issue of a short-lived, youthful shotgun wedding--to Richard's current girlfriend. When "Mrs. Lindem…

Safe Products for the Uncrunchy Mama

When I got pregnant, I became ultra-paranoid about toxins. (Haven't you heard? Pregnancy is the best time ever to become a paranoid schizophrenic!) At first I was drawn to everything "crunchy," from home organic gardening to no-poo hair care. I actually loved gardening and no-'poo, but they are not as simple or easy as you might be led to believe. Then I realized that all that crunches is not wholesome (there is just as much consumer-swindling, hazardous and unscientific BS in the "crunchy" sphere as in mainstream marketing toward women) and besides, I was too tired to make all my own soaps and cosmetics. And I didn't want to smell like patchouli and vinegar every day, much as I do love those two things. And I like my hair and skin and nails smooth, totally unlike my nut butter.

Fortunately, I found three great brands that offered everything I wanted: convenience, quality, reasonable price, and safety for me and my unborn child. Their products are luxu…